Key Takeaways
1. Women's forgotten history in medicine spans centuries
"Women have delivered healthcare across the globe for centuries as herbalists, healer-priestesses, shamans, apothecaries, healers, wise women, witch doctors, diviners, surgeons, nurses, and midwives."
Ancient roots. Women's involvement in medicine dates back to ancient civilizations. Notable figures include Agnodice, a 4th century BCE Athenian physician, and Alessandra Giliani, a 14th century Italian prosector who developed groundbreaking anatomical preservation techniques.
Medieval era. During the Middle Ages, nuns became primary practitioners of healing arts, tending to medicinal herb gardens and nursing ill villagers. Convents essentially functioned as proto-hospitals. However, the professionalization of medicine in the 13th century led to women's exclusion from formal medical education and practice.
Witch hunts. Between 1400 and 1700, the Catholic and Lutheran churches executed a campaign to eliminate wise women healers, branding them as witches. This resulted in the deaths of over 100,000 women healers, severely impacting women's role in healthcare for centuries to come.
2. Elizabeth Blackwell becomes America's first woman doctor
"I hate everything connected with the body and could not bear the sight of a medical book. The very thought of dwelling on the physical structure of the body and its various ailments fills me with disgust."
Unlikely beginnings. Elizabeth Blackwell's journey to becoming a doctor began with a dying friend's suggestion. Initially repulsed by the idea, Blackwell's determination to prove women's capabilities in medicine overcame her initial aversion.
Overcoming obstacles. Blackwell faced numerous rejections from medical schools before being accepted at Geneva Medical College in New York. She graduated top of her class in 1849, becoming the first woman to receive a medical degree in the United States.
Pioneering spirit. After graduation, Blackwell pursued further training in Paris and London. She established the New York Infirmary for Women and Children in 1857, providing medical care to poor women and children while offering training opportunities for aspiring women doctors.
3. Lizzie Garrett Anderson paves the way for British women in medicine
"I must have this or something else; I cannot live without some real work."
Determined pursuit. Elizabeth Garrett Anderson, inspired by Blackwell's example, embarked on a quest to become Britain's first woman doctor. She faced numerous rejections but persevered, piecing together a medical education through private tutoring and hospital experience.
Strategic approach. Garrett Anderson found a loophole in the Society of Apothecaries' regulations, allowing her to qualify as a licentiate in 1865. She later obtained an MD from the University of Paris, becoming the first woman on the British Medical Register.
Institutional impact. In 1866, Garrett Anderson opened the St. Mary's Dispensary for Women and Children in London, which later evolved into the New Hospital for Women. She also played a crucial role in establishing the London School of Medicine for Women in 1874.
4. Sophia Jex-Blake leads the charge for medical education in Edinburgh
"I do indeed congratulate you undergraduates with all my heart. It seems to me the grandest success that women have yet achieved in England; it is the great broad principle established that conducts to every noble progress."
Edinburgh campaign. Sophia Jex-Blake spearheaded the fight for women's admission to medical studies at the University of Edinburgh. In 1869, she and six other women became the first female matriculated students at a British university.
The Edinburgh Seven. Jex-Blake and her fellow students faced intense opposition from male students and faculty. The "Surgeons' Hall Riot" of 1870 brought national attention to their cause, garnering both support and criticism.
Legacy of persistence. Although the Edinburgh Seven were ultimately denied degrees, their efforts paved the way for future reforms. Jex-Blake went on to establish the London School of Medicine for Women and later the Edinburgh School of Medicine for Women.
5. Overcoming societal prejudice and institutional barriers
"The whole idea is disgusting! I could not entertain it for a moment."
Cultural resistance. Women pursuing medical careers faced deep-seated prejudice from society and the medical establishment. Common arguments against women doctors included:
- Lack of physical strength and mental capacity
- Unsuitability for the "indelicate" nature of medical work
- Disruption of social norms and family roles
Institutional obstacles. Universities and medical societies actively worked to exclude women:
- Refusing admission to medical schools
- Denying access to clinical training in hospitals
- Excluding women from professional organizations and conferences
Overcoming stereotypes. The pioneers had to prove that women could handle the rigors of medical education and practice without compromising their femininity or moral character. They demonstrated that women doctors could provide valuable care, especially to female patients who were often uncomfortable with male physicians.
6. Establishing women's medical schools and hospitals
"We have been facing these two perpendicular cliffs—money and skill—for fifteen years, and striving in every possible way to climb them. Little by little, however, we have laid one stone upon another, until we have gained a foundation sufficient to stand on."
Creating opportunities. Faced with exclusion from existing institutions, women doctors established their own medical schools and hospitals:
- New England Female Medical College (1848)
- Women's Medical College of Pennsylvania (1850)
- New York Infirmary for Women and Children (1857)
- London School of Medicine for Women (1874)
Comprehensive education. These institutions aimed to provide rigorous medical training comparable to men's schools, often emphasizing practical experience and clinical training.
Serving communities. Women's hospitals not only provided training grounds for female doctors but also addressed unmet healthcare needs, particularly for poor women and children who often lacked access to quality medical care.
7. The lasting impact of these pioneering women doctors
"I do not consider the time wasted. It seems to me that it is greatly due to the struggle in Edinburgh that it is now possible for women to obtain a fully qualifying medical education."
Opening doors. The efforts of Blackwell, Garrett Anderson, Jex-Blake, and others gradually led to the acceptance of women in medical education and practice:
- By 1900, there were over 7,000 women doctors in the United States
- Most British medical schools began admitting women by the early 20th century
Advancing women's health. Women doctors made significant contributions to:
- Obstetrics and gynecology
- Pediatrics
- Public health and preventive medicine
- Medical research and education
Ongoing legacy. The pioneering work of these women laid the foundation for future generations of female medical professionals:
- In 2019, women became the majority of U.S. medical school enrollees for the first time
- Recent research suggests that patients treated by women doctors have better outcomes in some areas
- Women continue to make important contributions to medical research and practice across all specialties
Last updated:
FAQ
What's Women in White Coats about?
- Historical Focus: Women in White Coats by Olivia Campbell explores the struggles and achievements of the first women doctors during the Victorian era, focusing on their fight for recognition in a male-dominated field.
- Key Figures: The book highlights pioneers like Elizabeth Blackwell, the first woman to earn a medical degree in the U.S., and her contemporaries who paved the way for future female physicians.
- Cultural Impact: It examines how these women not only transformed medicine but also challenged societal norms, contributing significantly to healthcare and women's rights.
Why should I read Women in White Coats?
- Inspiring Stories: The book offers motivating accounts of women who defied societal expectations to pursue careers in medicine, showcasing their resilience and determination.
- Rich Historical Context: Olivia Campbell provides a well-researched perspective on the often-overlooked contributions of women in medicine, enriching the reader's understanding of healthcare evolution.
- Relevance Today: Themes of gender equality and women's empowerment resonate with contemporary discussions, making it a timely and relevant read.
What are the key takeaways of Women in White Coats?
- Trailblazing Women: The book emphasizes the importance of pioneers like Elizabeth Blackwell, whose struggles laid the groundwork for future female doctors.
- Systemic Barriers: It highlights the societal prejudice and institutional discrimination women faced, serving as a reminder of the ongoing fight for equality.
- Legacy of Change: These women not only changed medicine but also inspired movements for women's rights and education, leaving a lasting legacy.
What are the best quotes from Women in White Coats and what do they mean?
- “Winning a doctor’s degree...”: Reflects Elizabeth Blackwell's view of her journey as a moral struggle for women's rights in a male-dominated field.
- “I believe it is here...”: Highlights the hope for equality in the medical profession, emphasizing America's perceived progressiveness over England.
- “The struggle with natural repugnance...”: Captures the internal conflict women faced when considering a medical career, illustrating societal expectations.
Who are the main women featured in Women in White Coats?
- Elizabeth Blackwell: Central to the narrative, she was the first woman to earn a medical degree in the U.S., setting a precedent for future female physicians.
- Sophia Jex-Blake: Fought for women's access to medical education in the UK, illustrating the challenges and triumphs of women entering the medical profession.
- Elizabeth Garrett Anderson: The first woman to qualify as a physician in Britain, she established the New Hospital for Women in London, advancing women's roles in healthcare.
What challenges did women face in pursuing medicine, as described in Women in White Coats?
- Institutional Barriers: Women were often barred from medical schools or ridiculed when they applied, forcing them to seek alternative paths.
- Social Prejudice: Societal beliefs that women were unfit for medicine created significant obstacles, questioning their intelligence and capability.
- Personal Sacrifices: Many faced familial opposition and societal isolation, requiring immense resilience and determination to pursue their careers.
How did Women in White Coats address the historical contributions of women in medicine?
- Recognition of Healers: Acknowledges that women have been healers throughout history, often overlooked in traditional medical narratives.
- Challenging Historical Narratives: Campbell highlights the significant roles women played, reframing the history of medicine to include their contributions.
- Legacy of Female Physicians: Emphasizes how early female physicians paved the way for future generations, essential to healthcare evolution.
How did the establishment of women’s medical schools impact the medical profession?
- Increased Access: Provided women with the opportunity for formal medical training, crucial for increasing the number of qualified female physicians.
- Challenging Stereotypes: Helped challenge stereotypes about women’s capabilities in medicine, shifting public perceptions.
- Legacy of Change: Laid the groundwork for future advancements in medical education and practice, influencing the ongoing fight for gender equality.
What role did public opinion play in the fight for women in medicine as discussed in Women in White Coats?
- Shaping Policy: Public opinion influenced medical institutions and government policies, with visibility garnering sympathy and support for change.
- Media Coverage: Brought attention to the challenges faced by women, rallying public support through coverage of events like the Surgeons’ Hall riot.
- Cultural Shifts: As women proved their competence, public opinion gradually shifted, vital for the acceptance of women in medicine.
How did the experiences of women in the UK compare to those in the US regarding medical education?
- Different Paths to Admission: In the US, Elizabeth Blackwell's success led to women's medical colleges, while UK women faced more systemic barriers.
- Public Perception: American women often faced less hostility, though both groups encountered challenges in gaining acceptance and respect.
- Legislative Changes: The US saw earlier legislative changes allowing women to practice, while the UK lagged until the late 19th century.
What was the significance of the Edinburgh Seven in the context of Women in White Coats?
- First Women Medical Students: Their enrollment marked a significant milestone, challenging the status quo and setting a precedent for future generations.
- Catalyst for Change: Their struggles brought national attention, prompting discussions and debates leading to policy changes.
- Legacy of Advocacy: Inspired many women to pursue medicine, contributing to the gradual acceptance of women in the profession.
How does Women in White Coats relate to contemporary discussions about women in medicine?
- Ongoing Gender Disparities: Highlights historical gender disparities, resonating with current challenges related to representation and equality.
- Inspiration for Future Generations: Early female physicians' stories inspire current and future women pursuing medical careers.
- Advocacy for Change: Encourages reflection on the importance of advocacy for women's rights, underscoring the need for continued efforts to address systemic barriers.
Review Summary
Women in White Coats chronicles the struggles of pioneering female doctors in the 19th century. Readers praised the book's engaging storytelling and meticulous research, highlighting the inspiring determination of Elizabeth Blackwell, Elizabeth Garrett Anderson, and Sophia Jex-Blake. Many found it eye-opening and appreciated learning about these trailblazers. Some critics noted issues with writing style, pacing, and modern language usage. Despite mixed opinions on execution, most agreed the subject matter was important and compelling.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.